Income Is How You Get Out of Poverty, Assets Are How You Stay Out

Posted by Alexandra Bastien on January 22, 2015

In Tuesday night’s State of the Union address, President Obama laid out a vision for rebuilding the middle class with pathways to the middle class for lower-income families. But to manifest this vision, we need a much stronger focus on addressing the root causes of concentrated, generational poverty: financial insecurity and lack of ownership.

In our work to build communities of opportunity where low-income people and people of color can thrive, we must acknowledge that income is how you get out of poverty, assets are how you stay out.

While income inequality in the U.S. recently hit its highest peak in 78 years, the wealth gap is even worse. The racial wealth gap—the difference in net worth between households of color and that of their white counterparts—has more than tripled since 1984. Today, African-American and Latino households have less than $1 in assets for every $6 that white households own. This is taking place in the context of a major demographic shift that will only magnify the costs of the racial wealth gap. By the end of the decade, the majority of youth will be people of color, and by 2044, the population majority overall will be people of color.

Assets and ownership are fundamental to economic opportunity and mobility. A child with a savings account in their own name is 2.5 times more likely to complete college than a child without one. That number jumps to 4.5 times more likely if that child is from a low-income household. Homeownership is linked to inheritance and access to credit, while access to credit is based on your income.

This is why all anti-poverty work should aim to result in financial empowerment and ownership. This doesn't mean that we all need to become experts in financial access, it does mean however, that regardless of the area of need—whether in health, education, housing, or serving the re-entry population—we should all have an eye toward connecting clients with partners who do have this expertise. For example, a bundled financial services model, such as those found in Financial Empowerment Centers, are available all over the country. Similar financial opportunity centers are hosted by the United Way and LISC and are helping low-income people with a range of financial issues from job placement to credit or foreclosure counseling, benefits assessments, tax preparation and more. These practices have had incredible success in helping families master their financial situations.

The time has come to use a more integrated approach to delivering these services. This can happen from many angles. In the community economic development field, worker-owned cooperatives are on the rise, addressing the problem of both unemployment and lack of ownership. In the public health sector, public health departments are using referral systems to connect low-income parents of newborns to financial coaching through home visiting programs. State and local governments are opening savings accounts for enrolled students in order to incentivize early savings for college. Additionally, innovations in capital-raising for small businesses are reshaping the rules around who can and should be an investor in community businesses. 

Chief Justice Louis Brandeis said it best: “We can have wealth concentrated in the hands of few, or we can have democracy, but we cannot have both.” The work of building an equitable economy in which all can participate and prosper cannot be complete if we provide jobs, but do not increase ownership. Helping low-income families master their financial positions does more than just balance their budget sheets. It changes a struggling person’s disposition with their finances—typically a large source of stress and shame. It frees up the mental energy that is typically spent battling financial issues and allows that person to plan for the future. Under our current political climate, particularly with Citizens United, addressing gaps in income and wealth now become an economic imperative as well as an imperative to uphold our democracy.

(Photo credit: Flickr user LendingClub.com, CC BY 2.0)

About the author more »

Alexandra Bastien is a Program Associate at PolicyLink where she works to lift up policy solutions to wealth inequality across the nation through a lens of equity. She manages www.accesstofinancialsecurity.org—a compendium of asset-building resources, conducts research and supports the PolicyLink financial security team. You can follow Alexandra on Twitter @Xandra_Bastie.

If you like this article, please subscribe to Shelterforce in print or make a small donation to keep Rooflines strong.

COMMENTS

Stacey Tice
27 Jan 15, 9:15 am

Creating opportunities for wealth creation, assets and income are not just about saving and investment. It is about a future story. Many low income families have a time horizon of days weeks and months and saving or staying in school is too far into the future to be worth the effort and realize the benefits. People in middle class families have a time horizon of years, making college and savings meaningful. Being poor is not just about not having money, but about managing what you have and setting priorities that go beyond next weeks trip to the grocery store. Middle class is willing to sacrifice now for a better future story for our children. My family doesn’t go on vacation or buy steaks so that my children can get degrees in engineering and medicine. Giving people assets without the right priorities will not change anything. Look at the number of professional athletes and lottery winners that end up bankrupt.

Matt Smith
27 Jan 15, 9:53 pm

While assets are great at building financial strength, they unfortunately don’t often provide much protection from middle-class people falling into poverty.

Middle-class people fall into poverty when 1) they lose their jobs and are out of work for a while, 2) lose their jobs and have to settle for lower-paying alternatives, 3) lose their homes, 4) lose their spouses, or 5) have expensive health emergencies.

You can spend a decade building equity in a home…and watch all of that vanish from being out of work for a stretch of months.

You can spend a decade investing in an employer retirement plan…and watch your value cut in half when the stock market plunges.

You can spend a decade making mortgage payments on a home…and still be “upside down” on it, unable to sell.

You can spend a decade making adjustable-rate mortgage-payments…and end up being poorer than when you started.

You can spend half a year’s earnings on a new vehicle…and try to sell it in a few years…only to find that it lost half of its value.

The solution?

The best way to keep middle-class people out of poverty is to keep them employed at good wages, have them live within their means, build credit, invest wisely, keep their families intact, and keep them healthy.

Assets are nice.  But investing in assets alone is no shortcut to staying out of poverty.

Holly
11 Jul 15, 4:24 pm

I come from a low income family. I know why we stayed poor while I was growing up. Lack of self-discipline, not budgeting for emergencies and a parent who worked very little. Now as an adult Im working two jobs which puts us closer to moderate income and I claim my mother as a dependent. Plus I’m putting money into savings and pushing for her to do the same w her fixed income. It doesn’t matter how much you have when its not managed properly. That’s why my mom and I were dirt poor for a long time.

POST YOUR COMMENTS register or login